Indicators of Downtown Health – Associated Documents
(Associated forms and resources may be downloaded below)
At their best, Vermont’s downtowns are vibrant community centers with shops, services, and civic functions all within walking distance. But many of our downtowns are threatened by sprawling development that drains investment away from community centers. In response, the state legislature has created a series of programs – from tax credits to planning assistance to priority for state facilities – that are designed to improve the vitality of community centers. What we don’t know is whether these and other programs are enough to get the job done. Is the health of our downtowns actually improving? And what exactly is a “healthy” downtown? In partnership with the University of Vermont’s Center for Rural Studies, Preservation Trust of Vermont, and the State Downtown Program, Smart Growth Vermont has launched an initiative to find answers to these very important questions.
We have developed a set of indicators of downtown health, and a handbook for how to use these indicators, for Vermont cities and villages that provide community leaders with an objective framework for measuring how well their downtowns are doing. In addition, the indicators will help communities evaluate and track the impacts of designated growth centers on downtowns. Through this web resources, Smart Growth Vermont will distribute the handbook and indicator list to communities across Vermont as well as work with the state Downtown Program to incorporate the indicators into the Growth Centers application process.
The project team identified and developed four broad categories of downtown health, each of which was measured via a series of data-driven indicators:
- Economic Vitality. This is a measure of economic well being of local citizens and the health of the town’s business and industrial sector. The indicators in this category measure the degree of investment in a downtown as well as levels of development activity.
- Livability and Cultural Identity. This is a measure of those qualities that make a location into a place. Community planning experts agree that a sense of place and community spirit are essential to the health of a community. These indicators measure how well a downtown is meeting the recreational, housing and transportation needs of its residents.
- Urban Form. This category is focused on spatial patterns of development, with measures of housing density, diversity of development, and municipal infrastructure. These measures will determine if growth is sprawling or compact.
- Regional Working Landscapes. A crucial measure of downtown health is the health of the downtown’s relationship with its rural surroundings. Given that one of Vermont’s land use goals is to maintain a pattern of compact settlements surrounded by working rural lands, we chose to examine a number of indicators related to farmers’ markets, availability of local products, and use of local foods at restaurants.
The team worked with four “test” communities of varying sizes around Vermont – Bristol, Burlington, Montpelier, and St. Albans – to pilot the indicators. With assistance and guidance from Smart Growth Vermont and the Center for Rural Studies, these communities collected data on each identified metric. The project team analyzed the data and added, deleted, or modified metrics as necessary. We then developed a weighting and scoring system that translated the raw data into easily understandable measures of the health of each downtown.
Developing, Collecting and Analyzing Indicators of Downtown Health: A Handbook, was developed as an outcome of this research project to provide a resource for other communities seeking measure the economic and overall health of their downtown.
Downloadable documents to assist in the indicator process:
Indicator List — Microsoft Word
Indicator Spreadsheet — Microsoft Excel
Chart of “Yes/No” Indicators — Microsoft Excel
Pre-data collection focus group questions — Microsoft Word
Post-data collection focus group questions — Microsoft Word
Self-Assessment — Microsoft Word
Hybrid Approach — PDF
Business Owners Survey — Microsoft Word
Mixed-use density maps — Microsoft Word
Working with Other Departments — Microsoft Word
|Thanks to our Funders!
We are grateful for support received for this project from the Windham Foundation, the Vermont Community Foundation, the Walter Cerf Community Fund and from the UVM Center for Rural Studies.